U4GM - 10 Valuable Items You Should Never Sell in Elden Ring
Elden Ring offers a massive world filled with treasures, loot, and consumables, many of which you’ll be tempted to offload for runes or inventory space. But as someone who's played through the game multiple times—and made a few painful mistakes along the way—I can tell you that not all items are created equal. Some Elden Ring Items are far more valuable than they first appear and should never be sold or discarded.
If you're working through your inventory or just defeated a boss and wondering what to keep, here are 10 items you absolutely should not sell. And if you’re looking to complete your build faster, remember there are options to buy cheap Elden Ring items online—but always from trusted sources.
1. Larval Tears
Used for respecs at Rennala, Larval Tears are a limited and precious commodity. They let you completely reassign your character's stats, which is essential for trying out new builds without starting over. I foolishly sold one in my first run and deeply regretted it when I needed to respec for a Faith build.
2. Stonesword Keys
While they may seem plentiful, these keys unlock fogged-off areas that often contain unique items, spells, or shortcuts. I once spent hours trying to recover an item locked behind a Stonesword imp statue, only to realize I had sold the key earlier. Learn from my mistake.
3. Remembrances
These are dropped by major bosses and can be exchanged for powerful weapons, sorceries, or incantations. Even if you're not using a particular build now, these Elden Ring Items can be incredibly useful in future playthroughs. Never sell them without checking what they unlock at Enia in Roundtable Hold.
4. Sacred Tears
Sacred Tears upgrade the potency of your healing flasks. They don’t take up weight or space, so there’s no reason to sell them. I once sold one out of ignorance thinking it was a basic consumable—huge mistake.
5. Crystal Tears
Used in the Flask of Wondrous Physick, these customizable effects can enhance your survivability, stamina regeneration, or even damage output. Their flexibility makes them irreplaceable tools in both PvE and PvP. Selling them for a few runes is never worth it.
6. Boss Weapons and Armor Sets
Even if you’re not using them in your current build, boss gear often carries special effects, lore, and high stats. I’ve returned to weapons like the Blasphemous Blade or Morgott’s Cursed Sword in later playthroughs. Holding onto them saved me from having to buy cheap Elden Ring items again.
7. Talisman Pouches
These expand the number of talismans you can equip, which significantly impacts your build's effectiveness. Since they’re acquired after specific progression points, you’ll never get a second chance to get one.
8. Upgrade Smithing Stones (Bell Bearings)
Once you find certain bell bearings, you can give them to the Twin Maiden Husks to unlock infinite smithing stones. Selling them means you might permanently lose access to that stone tier unless you refarm it or restart. I once lost out on Level 6 smithing stones because I sold a key bell bearing too early.
9. NPC Quest Items
From Dung Eater’s Seedbed Curse to Seluvis’s Potion, these are required for progressing certain side quests. Selling them can break questlines or cause you to miss out on endings, gear, or special spells. I’ve accidentally cut off an entire storyline this way before.
10. Dragon Hearts
Used at the Cathedral of Dragon Communion to acquire powerful dragon-based incantations, these hearts are surprisingly rare. I once sold one thinking I was done with that magic type, only to realize I needed it when I swapped to a Faith/Arcane hybrid build.
Inventory management in Elden Ring can feel overwhelming, but knowing what to keep and what to sell can save you hours of backtracking or regret. While it’s tempting to trade items for runes early on, the long-term value of these key Elden Ring Items outweighs the short-term gain.
And if you're short on time or accidentally sold something critical (we’ve all been there), I recommend looking into places to buy cheap Elden Ring items—just be sure to choose a trusted marketplace to avoid scams or account issues.
My own journey through the Lands Between has taught me that careful planning, a bit of hoarding, and a healthy respect for item rarity go a long way. Keep the right things, experiment wisely, and you’ll find that your builds will evolve much more smoothly than you ever expected.
Special Report: How Elden Ring Runes Affect Your Weapon Upgrades